
I got a puppy! His name is Dexter! I got a puppy!
RAAAR!!
So the pundits on the internets have already pretty well established why Top Design was a boring, poorly judged, joke of a show. I agree with all of these assessments, but in the name of thorough research, I watched anyway.
Well, it's that time of year again. While most normal people wait in cheerful expectation of spring or hunkered down doing midterms, for the last few years I've spent March occupied with one very serious concern: Nielson ratings. Somehow my shows always end up on the bubble, and this year is no exception. In fact, the same show is on the bubble. Again.
OK, so that's a lie. I can't live like this anymore. I feel like I can be honest with you, and the truth is this: I have watched The Black Donnellys. Twice.
Grey's Anatomy knows it's a primetime soap opera, and is completely unapologetic. That's its shtick. It's a show that does ferry crashes during sweeps and has subplots about passing syphilis. But The Black Donnellys, with its Paul Haggis pedigree, aspires to something else. The show quotes Yeats and attempts to engage questions of moral grayness. But the quotes are always puzzlingly detached from the plots and the closest interrogation of loyalty versus culpability is typed in all caps right on the black and white poster: FAMILY ABOVE ALL. It's a show trying to tell ambitious stories with a frustrated language, and the result is, well, frustrating.
So, it seems like I've kind of fallen down on the job of talking about Heroes and Lost. Both have been good-ish, but to be honest, I'm not feeling them lately. It's not them, it's me. I swear. But more than not enjoying them ('cause I kinda am), it's that I just don't want to write about them. And I think I've figured out why: secrets.
In an episode earlier this season, Jordan told Danny that she approached her new job at NBS as if she only had a year to live: the risks and rewards would be mitigated, and she could focus on doing the best possible job programming the network. This may be, in fact, how Aaron Sorkin chose to approach Studio 60. Man, was that a bad idea.
Alas, Studio 60 is really starting to blow. How do I feel? Saddened, yes. Disappointed, certainly. But more significantly, I feel betrayed.
Episode 3-11 Show Me the Monkey
Mac’s smoochin’ on the porch by the end of the ep. But there’s more, not-so-wholesome smooching going on elsewhere in Neptune. Dick has convinced Logan to quit moping and go surfing, where they meet up with Easter Egg Ass Chip and the three of them do some surfer skanks who aren’t too ugly. Logan’s bathing beauty is figuratively (if not literally) wiping her chin as she coos “I can’t believe I just did that with Aaron Echoll’s son.” Man, Logan you can’t win for trying. Even sluts don’t respect you. Meanwhile, in the food court…
Parting thoughts
Heroes - I just picked this one up over the winter break. Everyone seemed to be raving about it, so I took the liberty of downloading several episodes on iTunes to find out for myself. (Only after downloading six episodes did I realize I could watch them streaming on nbc.com. Oops.) The series starts a bit slow, with so many characters to introduce and follow. And I do think that over the entire half season that's aired so far, that's really the weakness of the show: trying to cater to too many stories, stars, and characters. Ensemble casts are fantastic, but Heroes really should take a page from Lost and focus on only one or two characters per episode to take the pressure off the storytelling. I'm also not loving the Nikki/Jessica storyline featuring Ali Larter. I don't know if it's the acting or the character, but it seems much more melodramatic and twirling-mustachioed than the other threads.
Lost - The show that launched a thousand sci-fi series. The first season was groundbreaking, engaging, and enthralling. The second season was less so. Now six episodes into Season 3, we're waiting through a long hiatus for the final 16 episodes. In my opinion, the introduction of the "Others" has benefited the series in a way the "Tailies" did not. The Tailies seemed like a mere shark-jump to infuse new characters, while the Others really do provide new stories, perspectives, and possibilities. That said, watching Jack, Sawyer, and Kate remain in captivity for six episodes has been bor-ing. Time to set them free and move the plot along. Pronto. Wednesdays, 10/9c on ABC.
Studio 60 (on the Sunset Strip) - I'm willing to admit that the Cheese Might Stand Alone on this one. I know that some things on this show are not working. I know that many have been pretty disappointed. I know that some of the sketches are not funny. But regardless, I am a fan of Aaron Sorkin come hell or cancellation. I don't need to rehash my eternal love of all things West Wing and Sports Night. But the fast-talking, behind-the-scenes, incessantly-optimistic worldview Sorkin draws in every script is irresistible to me. I can't hate on it.
Top Chef - Along with Project Runway, Top Chef is really putting Bravo's original programming on the map. I don't even cook or watch cooking shows, but the talent and artistry associated with producing fine cuisine is fascinating. And the bitching. I really like the bitching. I liked the first season, but this second season is even better. Gone is boring-vanilla Billy Joel's wife as host, and in her place is interesting-Indian Salman Rushdie's wife. As for the contestants, Elan is adorable, Betty is hilarious, Marcel is cartoonish, and Michael is, as guest judge Anthony Bourdain put it, Flinstonian. The food is hot, Padma Lakshmi is smokin, and the competition is sizzling. Wow, that was chee-sy. Wednesdays, 10/9c on Bravo.
Veronica Mars - My favorite show. Season 1 broke noir ground, Season 2 paced back over it, and Season 3 is dragging it to college. The move to Hearst College hasn't been easy for Veronica or Veronica Mars, but after the first mini-arc of nine episodes, this season may be finding its stride. The combined forces of the move to the CW, its pairing with the waning Gilmore Girls, and the ever-present ratings crisis have forced writer/creator Rob Thomas to pander a bit to new, younger audiences. This means that references to previous seasons have been minimized, Kristen Bell's wardrobe has been sexed up, and the noir elements have been toned down. Oh, and V's kinda bitchy now.
Today is my birthday, and historically, it hasn't been the most wonderful day of the year for me. I won't go into the many New Year's Eve and football-related obstacles, but suffice it to say that I've learned expectations are never a good thing when talking about birthdays.